Human resources auditing as an HR decision-making tool: a literature review
Keywords:
Human resource audit, HR decision-making, contingency factors, bounded rationality, integrative literature reviewAbstract
Human resources auditing has gradually established itself within the HR function as a diagnostic and management tool that goes beyond its traditional role of control and compliance. Yet its contribution to HR decision-making remains poorly systematised: there is no framework linking HR audit types, the stages of the decision process and the conditions under which audit information is actually used. This article asks the following question: to what extent does human resources auditing constitute a relevant tool for supporting HR decision-making?
Based on an integrative review of 19 works published between 1988 and 2025, identified through Google Scholar and Cairn.info, the article highlights three ways in which HR auditing contributes to decision-making: reducing information uncertainty, helping to anticipate organisational needs, and strengthening the strategic alignment of HR practices. These contributionsrest more on conceptual claims than on empirical evidence.
However, the analysis shows that this contribution is not systematic, but is influenced by three families of contingency factors: cultural (national culture, perception of time, team diversity), organisational (consistency with the HR system, maturity of the HR function, auditor independence) and institutional (legal framework), which shape the way in which HR decision-makers seek out, evaluate and translate information from the HR audit into decisions.
The conclusions of this analysis suggest moving beyond a purely technical view of the HR audit, in order to regard it as a mechanism whose decision relevance is closely linked to the organisational and cultural context in which it is implemented. The article derives a conceptual model with seven research propositions, together with implications for HR directors, auditors and executives.
JEL Classification: D81, M12, M42, M14, M51
Paper type: Theoretical research (integrative review and conceptual model)
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2026 Ahlame OUMELLAIK, Mohamed SABRI

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
Copyright is held by the authors under this licence.
CC-BY-NC-ND.
Any work submitted that is suspected of being pirated or plagiarism is entirely the responsibility of the submitting author.


















