Dividend irrelevance theory in the financial sector of emerging markets: A literature review
Keywords:
Dividend irrelevance theory, dividend policy, financial sector, emerging markets, share price volatility, financial performanceAbstract
The literature on the dividend policy of financial firms is limited compared with that on other sectors and mainly covers advanced markets. Moreover, the empirical findings are inconsistent, particularly regarding whether dividends affect value, share price behaviour, and financial performance. Drawing on dividend irrelevance theory, this paper reviews the main theoretical arguments and empirical evidence regarding dividend policy of financial firms in emerging markets. Specifically, this study focuses on whether prior literature supports or challenges the dividend irrelevance theory in the context of the financial sector in emerging markets. To address this question, the paper adopts a semi-systematic literature review approach and develops an integrative qualitative synthesis of theoretical contributions and empirical evidence. It contributes to the literature by relating divergent evidence on dividend irrelevance to the regulatory, informational and stakeholder mechanisms that characterise financial institutions in emerging markets.
The synthesis of 15 selected empirical studies indicates mixed evidence on the extent to which dividend irrelevance theory applies in this setting. Some studies suggest that dividend policy has a limited or nonsignificant influence on value, share-price volatility or financial performance, while others document the relevance of dividends to investors and depositors and their association with market assessments of financial firms. These divergent findings suggest that the relevance of dividends may depend on market frictions, heterogeneity across financial systems, the institutional environment, and the particular characteristics of financial firms.
Future research should prioritise theoretical explanations of dividend relevance, comparable empirical designs and evidence from underrepresented financial institutions and markets. Bibliometric analysis can help map the intellectual framework and evolution of the "dividend puzzle". Future work should combine qualitative studies of managerial perspectives with comparable quantitative designs that account for regulatory change and the institutional settings of financial firms.
JEL classification: G21; G35; G32
Paper type: Theoretical research (literature review).
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2026 Soufiane AKHKHA

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
Copyright is held by the authors under this licence.
CC-BY-NC-ND.
Any work submitted that is suspected of being pirated or plagiarism is entirely the responsibility of the submitting author.


















